You don't have to suffer alone GET IN TOUCH
Women calculating tax on settlement

Will I Be Taxed on My Personal Injury Settlement?

G. Aldrich Law May 8, 2024

After dealing with a personal injury, you've been through the physical, legal, and financial wringer. So, when it comes time to receive your settlement, the last thing you want is for Uncle Sam to take a big chunk out of it.  

Personal injury settlements are typically not taxed by the IRS. This policy is in place so that victims don't get penalized for receiving necessary compensation for their injuries. But, there are exceptions to be wary of so that you aren't caught off-guard come tax season.  

Here's what you need to know:  

A settlement purely for damages associated with a physical injury or illness will generally be exempt from tax liability. 

In other words, the tax implications of a personal injury settlement depend on the type of damages awarded.  

Generally speaking, the taxation of a settlement is based on three kinds of damages: actual (or compensatory), emotional distress, and punitive. 

If your settlement encompasses compensation for actual costs incurred as a result of an injury, these amounts are typically not taxable. The underlying principle, 'compensation for loss', posits that the funds received serve a restorative purpose. This aligns with the tax-exempt status of payments made to recuperate from losses, enhancing the clarity and efficiency of financial recovery processes. 

These damages include:  

  • Medical Expenses: Immediate medical expenses are generally seen as reimbursing a loss, which is not considered income.  

  • Property Damage: Reimbursement for repair or replacement of damaged property is non-taxable.   

  • Lost Wages: Money received to cover lost wages tends to not be taxed, as this amount replaces income that would have been earned had the injury not occurred.  

Emotional Distress  

The tax status of emotional damages depends on their connection to physical injury. Compensation for emotional distress caused by physical injury is also not typically taxable. However, emotional distress without physical injury is taxable. In summary: 

  • Compensation for emotional distress from physical injury is non-taxable. 

  • Emotional distress without a physical cause may be taxed. 

Punitive Damages   

In personal injury cases, punitive damages are awarded to the plaintiff to punish the defendant for reckless or harmful behavior.  

Unlike compensatory damages, punitive damages are typically taxable because they do not fall under the restorative principle. In other words, the purpose of punitive damages is to punish, rather than compensate for a loss.   

Exceptions to the General Guidelines 

While the above provides a solid overview, keep in mind that exceptions apply to particular types of injuries or settlements that have unique structures. 

For example, legal settlements under acts like the Black Lung Benefits Act are specifically designated as exempt by the IRS. 

Key exceptions to be aware of include: 

  • Statutory Exemptions: Certain settlements under specific legislation may be exempt from taxation. 

  • Explosives-related Injuries: In specific situations, the IRS provides exemptions for punitive damages related to personal physical injuries.  

How an Attorney Can Help 

Having a knowledgeable personal injury lawyer in your corner can be a game changer regarding how your settlement is taxed. Your attorney can provide essential guidance by: 

  • Reviewing Your Settlement Structure: Attorneys can examine the specifics of your settlement to determine how it may be taxed. By doing this, they can help identify portions of the settlement that are taxable versus those that are not. 

  • Advising on Taxable Amounts: They can give you information on which parts of your settlement might be considered income by the IRS and which are exempt. This is crucial for planning and managing the funds you receive. 

  • Structuring the Settlement: In many cases, how a settlement is structured can influence its tax implications. Your attorney can work to structure your settlement in a way that minimizes the taxable portion, where possible. 

  • Guidance on IRS Documentation: They can advise you on the correct forms and documentation needed to report your settlement correctly to the IRS, ensuring compliance while maximizing your financial recovery. 

  • Negotiating With Insurers: Attorneys are skilled in negotiating settlements that clearly categorize damages in a manner that is most advantageous to you from a tax perspective. 

  • Avoiding Pitfalls: Experienced legal counsel can foresee potential tax pitfalls and work to avoid them, saving you money and stress in the long run. 

Explore Your Legal Options 

There's no doubt that navigating the aftermath of a personal injury can be complex and overwhelming. But understanding the tax implications of your settlement is key to ensuring you're not caught off guard by unexpected fiscal responsibilities.  

By familiarizing yourself with the tax exemptions and obligations detailed above, you'll be better equipped to manage your settlement wisely. However, it's always recommended to seek professional legal advice to avoid potential tax pitfalls and ensure your settlement is structured optimally for both your financial and physical recovery.  

An essential takeaway is that the goal of a personal injury settlement is to aid in your recuperation, not to provide additional stress. With the right guidance, you can achieve a settlement outcome that supports your recovery and secures your financial future. 

Contact us at G. Aldrich Law for steadfast support in any personal injury case or matter. We're proud to serve clients throughout Lakeport and Woodland Hills, California, as well as Lake County, Los Angeles County, Colusa County, Riverside County, and the surrounding Northern and Southern California communities.